Policy
Indian Companies In A Fix Over Developments In Venezuela
more...


Will International Oil Market Favour Prime Minister Modi?
more...


Transnational Gas Pipelines Continue To Elude India
more...


Inevitable Confusion: Gas vs Electricity As Transportation Fuels
more...


Petroleum Subsidy Set For Big Jump In Next Fiscal
more...

Regulation
ONGC: From Vision 2030 To Strategic Roadmap 2040
more...


India’s Gas Hydrate Program Entering Crucial Phase
more...


High Speed Diesel Flash Point Needs To Be Reviewed
more...


Tenth CGD Round Poised For Big Success
more...

Alternative Energy / Fuel
Trend Of Renewable Energy Capacity in India
more...

New Projects
IndianOil To Set Up Monoethylene Glycol Plant At Paradip Refinery
more...


IndianOil To Set Up LPG Import Terminal At Paradip
more...


GAIL Cancels IL&FS’ Contract To Construct Bokaro–Durgapur Pipeline Project
more...

Market Watch
India Becomes The World’s Second Largest Importer Of LPG
more...


Over 400,000 Applications Received For 78,500 Petrol Pump Dealerships
more...

Companies
Jindal Drilling & Industries Limited
more...


Scientific Design To Provide Process Technology To IndianOil MEG Plant
more...


L&T Hydrocarbon Engineering Bags Two Orders From IOC
more...


Asian Oilfield Services Ltd Reports Financial Performance
more...

Press Release [FREE Access]
Petro Intelligence » Darker Truths Behind Roadblocks To Mega Refinery

by R. Sasankan

The best laid plans of mice and men/Gang aft a-gley, wrote Scottish poet Robert Burns – meaning that the most-carefully crafted strategies can often go awry. Back in April, when Aramco of Saudi Arabia, the world’s biggest oil company, signed an agreement with India’s top state-owned oil marketing companies to pick up a 50 per cent state in a 60 million ton refinery on the west coast, it was thought that the ambitious project would finally get off the ground and things would move very quickly.

Sanjiv SinghAramco soon roped in ADNOC, the state-owned giant of United Arab Emirates, as an equity partner in the venture and it did seem that everything would move swimmingly well. The only sticking point was the location of the controversial project that would require 14,000 acres of land in the Ratnagiri district of Maharashtra that would entail large-scale displacement of people.

But it now seems that there are more roadblocks that the project will need to work around as concerns mount over the way that this mammoth investment could change the landscape in the petroleum sector, jeopardising the interests and ambitions of both the existing public and private players.

Saudi energy minister Khalid al-Falih, who was present at the ceremony where Aramco signed the accord, had given some indication of what the Gulf nation was really looking for.

“Large as this project may be, it does not by itself satisfy our desire to invest in India... We see India as a priority for investments and for our crude supplies,” al-Falih had said. “We’re very much interested in retail... We want to be consumer-facing. ”

Al-Falih’s statement rubbished the popular perception in India that big crude oil producers such as Saudi Arabia, UAE and Kuwait want to invest in Indian refinery sector just to ensure a market for their crude oil. That is just not true and India’s petroleum industry has started to quickly wisen up to the strategies and ambition of the high rollers from the Middle East and the West.

D. RajkumarThe oil giant, Exxon Mobil, is launching a $15 million ad campaign in the Indian media. It has no significant visible stake in the Indian market so far. Shell is reportedly in the race for a stake in the Bina refinery of BPCL in which Oman Oil Company is partner. What explains this sudden rush to get into the Indian market? Petroleum experts believe the only logical explanation is to gain a foothold in the world’s largest potential market. If India ever becomes a middle income country, petroleum consumption will need to rise 2.5 times, at the very least, from current levels. No other country offers such a potential today in the world.

The big players – all with deep pockets – are clearly not looking to make immediate profits. They want to position themselves as players in India’s vast market for which they need marketing rights. But it isn’t going to be an easy ride. The Indian government grants marketing rights to anyone who invests Rs 20 billion ($280 million) in the petroleum sector. That is peanuts for these oil majors. Shell got it more than a decade ago by virtue of its investment in Hazira LNG terminal but has been struggling to set up the retail outlets with a tally of just 100 against the licensed permission for 1500 outlets. BP, which got marketing rights for transportation fuels last year, is still undecided about what to do with it.

Petroleum marketing is an area where even a highly aggressive company like Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) could not succeed. This is because the state-owned IOC, BPCL and HPCL enjoy a stranglehold over the marketing infrastructure. It is hard to build new marketing infrastructure from scratch. It took the state-owned giants more than five to six decades to create the sprawl they now have. The hard truth is that a private player must piggyback on the strengths of these state-owned giants. Moreover, the Mundra port is the only one with good terminal facilities for a private player.

The Indian PSUs do not want to be a pawn in the strategies that these overseas players intend to use to grab market share in India. They fear that these giants would flood the Indian markets with their products if they get a window of opportunity. Since their cost of crude is only $10 per barrel, these global behemoths can dump their products at absurdly low prices.

Is that why the mega refinery project has started to run into roadblocks? It’s hard to tell. There is a lot of hard bargaining that is going on behind the scenes. Aramco’s sudden interest in investing in the Bina refinery cannot be without significance. It could well be looking to hedge its bets if the west coast mega refinery is inordinately delayed.

M.K. SuranaIndian Oil Corporation (IOC) was the original leader of the state-owned consortium that proposed the mega refinery on the west coast. IOC, which has no refining capacity on the west coast, was to have a 50 per cent stake in the mega refinery with BPCL and HPCL sharing the rest in equal proportion. The fact is that IOC had not taken any initiative in inviting Aramco as an equity partner in the venture. That decision was foisted on the state-owned companies by the political leadership. IOC is not a lightweight and its concerns cannot be ignored easily by the government. Will IOC try to get rid of Aramco? The Saudi giant’s entry cannot be in the interest of Reliance Industries either since the mega project could threaten the fortunes of its Jamnagar facilities. Although Aramco has excellent relations with RIL and IOC, these equations can quickly change when it becomes a matter of survival.

Experts say that if the government is keen to bring foreign investment into the refinery sector, it will have to restructure the petroleum sector in such a way as to ensure a level playing field for all. India, they contend, should have no more than two strong integrated national oil companies and the barriers to the entry into the Indian market should be removed.

Indian consumers suffered when the price of Indian basket of crude oil was ruling at over $117 per barrel. They did not benefit when the prices crashed to $ 24 a barrel because the government soaked up the benefits through an excise duty on auto fuels even as the oil marketing companies ratcheted up their after-tax profits significantly.

It is clear that the hapless Indian consumer will stand to benefit if there is greater competition. What is wrong if someone is able to market LPG more cheaply? Strong regulation is the answer and not the creation of entry barriers. Public sector efficiency will also increase if there is healthy competition. It should be in the country’s long term interest to open up markets and level the playing field.



To download the latest issue 'Volume 25 Issue 21 - February 10, 2019', click here
Petro Intelligence [FREE Access]
War Of Words On Wisdom Of Subsidizing Refinery Exports
more...

Refinery Exports: A Bane And A Burden On Indian Consumers
more...

Clash Of Egos Bedevil Mega Refinery Project
more...

Saudi Tweet Stokes A Storm Of Speculatio
more...

Foreign Investment
Six Foreign Companies Bid In Second Auction
more...

Overseas Investment
Essar Acquires Stakes In BP’s Oil Terminals, Pipeline To Expand In UK
more...


OVL Awaits Overdue Dividends From Crisis Hit Venezuela
more...

Gas Scene
Domestic Gas Scene in December 2018
more...


Capacity Utilization of Gas Pipelines
more...


Update: PNG Connections
more...


LNG Import Projection By Industry Group
more...


Status Of Gas Pipelines Under Construction
more...


Trends In Domestic Natural Gas Price & International Bench Marks
more...


Capacity Utilization of LNG Regasification Terminals
more...


Story Of Two LNG Terminals Of Petronet LNG Ltd
more...


CNG Growth Over The Years & CNG Sales as on 1st April, 2018
more...


LNG Terminals in India
more...


CGD Factsheet As Of Sept 2018
more...


A total picture about Natural Gas scene including CBM in India
more...


State-Wise Share In CGD Business
more...


Update: Sectoral Consumption of Natural Gas, LNG Import and Total Net Available Gas for Sale
more...


Declining Rate Of Gas Flaring In ONGC’s Fields
more...

Data Section
Monthly Upstream Data
Monthly Downstream Data
Historical database
Data Archives
Special Database
Merger & Acquisitions In The Indian Oil And Gas Sector
more...


Company-wise Length & Capacity of Product and Crude Pipelines in India
more...


Energy Transition Index for India
more...


Energy Architecture Performance Index for India
more...


Estimated Basin-wise Hydrocarbon Resources in India
more...


Categories of Indian Sedimentary Basins
more...


Forward Path for India-Economic Growth, Energy and Climate Change - Some Introspection
more...


India’s Declining Self- Sufficiency In Petroleum Products
more...


India: Per-capita Energy Consumption & Energy Intensity
more...


Increasing Share of High Sulphur Crude in Indian Refineries
more...


Energy Trilemma Index
more...


Power Availability Improves In December 2018
more...


Petroleum Products Import Falls In December 2018
more...


Share of Imports From OPEC Declined In December 2018
more...


Vedanta’s Oil & Gas Production Marginally Down In 2018
more...


Oil Import - Volume And Value
more...


Major End use of petroleum products in India
more...


Fuel & Loss In Indian Refineries: An Update
more...


Update: Distillate Yield of PSU refineries
more...


Bharat Petroleum Corporation’s Impressive Refining Coverage
more...


Update: Specific Energy Consumption of PSU Refineries
more...


India Imports Less Petroleum Products In November 2018
more...


OIL’s In-House Capabilities & Infrastructure to support E&P Activities
more...

Tenders [FREE Access]
BPCL
more...


IndianOil
more...